Electronic Supplement to
Comparing the CENA GMPEs Using NGA-East Ground-Motion Database

by L. P. Ogweno and C. H. Cramer

Table S6 Results of Classical Residual Analysis for Deep Soil Sites

GMPEs PGA (258) 0.1 s (175) 0.2 s (255) 0.3 s (256) 0.5 s (255) 1.0 s (250) 2.0 s (206) Factor Rank
EP04d 0.257(0.050) 0.055(0.067) 0.246(0.048) 0.203(0.048) 0.152(0.046) 0.043(0.038) −0.044(0.041) 0.143 1
EP04b 0.434(0.049) 0.232(0.067) 0.133(0.048) 0.085(0.049) 0.053(0.049) 0.037(0.041) 0.038(0.046) 0.145 2
A08p 0.388(0.048) 0.180(0.070) 0.108(0.048) −0.008(0.049) −0.014(0.052) −0.146(0.050) −0.263(0.056) 0.158 3
AB06p 0.053(0.050) 0.039(0.074) 0.007(0.051) −0.109(0.050) −0.227(0.049) −0.348(0.043) −0.465(0.047) 0.178 4
AB06+ −0.022(0.050) −0.035(0.073) −0.048(0.051) −0.151(0.050) −0.255(0.049) −0.373(0.043) −0.489(0.047) 0.196 5
EP04a 0.414(0.047) 0.217(0.066) 0.215(0.048) 0.217(0.048) 0.204(0.047) 0.051(0.040) −0.082(0.046) 0.200 6
A08 0.568(0.048) 0.300(0.066) 0.272(0.048) 0.211(0.049) 0.124(0.048) 0.038(0.039) −0.160(0.043) 0.239 7
SD02 0.617(0.048) 0.169(0.067) 0.383(0.047) 0.272(0.048) 0.155(0.047) 0.039(0.040) −0.048(0.042) 0.240 8
PZT11 −0.450(0.052) −0.382(0.075) −0.193(0.053) 0.121(0.052) 0.008(0.051) 0.187(0.043) 0.348(0.048) 0.241 9
AB06 −0.103(0.050) −0.117(0.073) −0.109(0.051) −0.196(0.050) −0.286(0.049) −0.400(0.043) −0.515(0.047) 0.246 10
SC02 0.524(0.047) 0.078(0.067) 0.387(0.048) 0.335(0.048) 0.269(0.047) 0.095(0.041) −0.079(0.046) 0.252 11
AB95 0.539(0.051) 0.476(0.073) 0.391(0.050) 0.305(0.049) 0.178(0.046) 0.031(0.039) −0.104(0.044) 0.289 12
S01 0.439(0.050) 0.295(0.067) 0.492(0.048) 0.396(0.048) 0.283(0.046) 0.171(0.038) 0.035(0.041) 0.302 13
TP05 0.387(0.049) 0.318(0.073) 0.466(0.051) 0.638(0.049) 0.130(0.048) 0.176(0.041) 0.277(0.043) 0.342 14
EP04c 0.663(0.055) 0.429(0.077) 0.351(0.052) 0.305(0.050) 0.268(0.047) 0.225(0.038) 0.286(0.042) 0.361 15
F96 0.621(0.050) 0.553(0.073) 0.513(0.050) 0.446(0.049) 0.298(0.047) 0.104(0.041) −0.030(0.044) 0.367 16
SV02 0.816(0.048) 0.370(0.067) 0.624(0.048) 0.515(0.048) 0.373(0.047) 0.119(0.042) −0.083(0.049) 0.414 17
C03 0.781(0.052) 0.690(0.076) 0.666(0.052) 0.628(0.051) 0.449(0.048) 0.338(0.039) 0.260(0.043) 0.545 18
T02 0.827(0.051) 0.721(0.069) 0.846(0.050) 0.730(0.049) 0.620(0.047) 0.543(0.038) 0.209(0.044) 0.642 19

Mean residuals for distances ≤100 km are shown for seven periods; “Factor” shows the average of the absolute value of the seven mean residuals. Numbers in parentheses in the column heads are the numbers of observations at each period; numbers in parentheses after the data indicate standard deviation; colored values show position in the hierarchy of the GMPE as given by the factor column (red, rank one; green, rank two; and blue, rank three). A positive value indicates over prediction and a negative value indicates under prediction by the model.

[ Back ]