High-Flying Experiments Demonstrate Potential of Balloon-Borne Infrasound Detection

18 April 2017-DENVER — Experiments conducted high in the skies over New Mexico suggest that balloon-borne sensors could be useful in detecting the infrasound signals generated by small, extraterrestrial debris entering Earth’s atmosphere, according to a report at the 2017 SSA Annual Meeting.

Launch of the infrasound payload at Ft. Sumner, New Mexico/ Eliot Young/NASA/SWRI

Infrasound, sometimes called low-frequency sound, is sound waves that occur at frequencies lower than the limit of human hearing. Infrasound signals can remain strong as they travel over large distances, making them useful for pinpointing the location and size of events such as nuclear explosions, meteorite strikes, volcanic eruptions and sometimes earthquake ruptures.

Ground sensors can detect these signals, but very small infrasound signals can be swamped out by wind and other ambient noises gathered by these devices. So researchers including Eliot Young of the Southwest Research Institute and Daniel Bowman of Sandia National Laboratories are looking for quieter places to position these sensors — in this case tethering them to high-altitude balloons.

“Balloons are good for this because they float in the ambient wind field, which eliminates the wind noise that you would get with a ground sensor,” explained Young. “The temperature of Earth’s atmosphere is also such that it creates an infrasound waveguide-a place in the stratosphere where infrasound energy is concentrated and doesn’t dissipate in the normal way.”

To test the sensitivity of balloon-borne detectors, Young and his colleagues arranged three large ground explosions (equivalent to about 2400 pounds of TNT) to occur while they flew infrasound sensors on a balloon flying at an altitude of 35 kilometers, or nearly 22 miles in the air. The flying sensors were able to detect all three explosions at that height, and at a lateral distance away from the explosions of about 350 to 400 kilometers, or between 220 and 250 miles away (Download a movie of the balloon launch here).

This means that the sensors, Young said, “are sensitive to objects about the size of bowling balls coming in and exploding in Earth’s atmosphere.”

Building a sensor that could detect such small signals was a significant challenge, said University of Colorado, Boulder’s Viliam Klein, who worked on the balloon project. As the balloon rises in altitude, the change in atmospheric pressure on the balloon also changes, and the pressure waves are larger than infrasound waves. “If you raise your arm off a desk, you’re experiencing a change of about three pascals of atmospheric pressure,” Klein said. “But the amplitude of the waves we want to measure is about .06 pascals.”

This fact made calibrating the sensors on the ground difficult. When the lab’s AC system disrupted the process, for example, the researchers put the sensor rig inside a refrigerator, but even the noise from the fridge compressor was too disruptive, said Klein. “Everything generates pressure waves bigger than we wanted to see.”

Bowman also flew a smaller solar balloon at a lower altitude — about 15 kilometers — during the experiment. The solar balloon was able to detect one of the explosions, and the researchers noted that the amplitude of the infrasound signal was about five times stronger than that detected by the high-altitude balloon. “It looks like you gain the advantage of no ambient wind noise with a lower balloon, but you don’t have the disadvantage of being so high up that the pressure has really dropped and your signals are small,” Young said.